Tuesday, January 03, 2006

Where everybody knows your name

I remember hearing once, when Everybody Loves Raymond went off the air, that it was the last great sitcom on television. While that might not be completely true, as My Name is Earl and 2 1/2 Men are both quite good and clever, there does seem to be a dearth of quality sitcoms anymore. I don't think this is due so much to a desire to watch real crime shows (seriously, I can't handle another Bruckheimer cop show that's slick in appearance, but completely hollow on story). Instead, I think it comes from laziness in the writers. Too often, sitcom writers resort to stereotypes and/or sex/gas jokes as opposed to working to create humor. If you look at the really great sitcoms of the last 30 years (Friends doesn't count, it's pop culture gone berserk), they almost all have something in common: characters who have personalities, be they intelligent, dim, or somewhere in between. They are more than one-dimensional. You can relate to the people, and you get to think while you watch them. This is lost too often by writers who think they have are writing to the audience.

So, I hereby list the following truly classic sitcoms of my generation:

All in the Family - Archie was so bigoted and so unaware of it, that you watched him just to see how stupid he could be. This started it all, and included clever writing, which has been lost over the years.

The Bob Newhart Show - Bob Newhart is one of the best comics of this age. He can do more with a look than most young comics can do with anything. The cast all worked together so well, and knew when to throw in the towel.

MASH - I think this might be the second-best sitcom ever. It took a difficult subject in a difficult time, and gave us characters we love, messages we can apply in many situations, and a comaraderie that overpowered everything. Few shows can work in new characters with the skill these surgeons did. Excellence all around.

Newhart - Another Bob Newhart show. Bob is the only intelligent person in Vermont, and he gets to deal with molehill after molehill that everyone else turns into mountains. You love him, because you feel like you're living his life every day. Best final episode ever.

Cheers - This is the greatest sitcom ever.

Night Court - Zany, crazy characters doing the zany crazy things that other ensembles could never get away with (putting Groucho glasses on the Statue of Liberty?!). Crazy.

Seinfeld - Notices the little things and points out how crazy people get letting them take over their lives. He did it in a not-quite-subtle way that worked, but I doubt could ever be duplicated.

Frazier - Takes a psychiatrist who's looming on the edge of sanity, combines him with his equally precariously balanced brother, their dad, who acts like a dad should, his quirky assistant and Niles's would-be love interest, and Frazier's assistant, a loud-mouthed crazy woman in her own right. Christopher Lloyd produced the first few seasons, which were magical, and, after he left, the show took a turn downward, until thelast season, when he came back again. Terrific, and classy. Second-best final episode ever.

Everyone Loves Raymond - The family from hell. Ray is such a doofus, and everyone in his family has its own personality (except the kids, who were necessary, but mostly as window dressing). Few family comedies can work together this well.

That's it. Nine shows, out of the hundreds that have come out over the years. These are the classics. There have been other good shows, but most have been tripe. Again, you'll notice something special in these shows, something that other shows don't quite have. Would that it happened a little more often.

5 comments:

Michelle said...

I agree. You only have to look at University enrollments here for degrees in Forensic Science....absolutely crazy! Thankfully many drop out after 1st when they realise it aint what you see on tv!
I adored Bob Newhart..."This is my brother Daryl, and my other brother Daryl and my other brother Daryl!

English Professor said...

We love "Raymond," even though that marks us as uncool with some of the younger crowd. My husband is notoriously hard to buy for, but the first three seasons of "Raymond" on DVD was a huge hit.

I agree with almost all of your picks, with one caveat: some blowhards didn't understand that Archie Bunker was a buffoon, and instead saw the show as validation of their own bigotry. I rarely watched Seinfeld, but I'm delighted to see Night Court on your list.

Another plus for Bob Newhart--his appeal is truly multi-generational, and you can count on him being a class act wherever he appears.

Steve said...

The list was actually a little more difficult than I'd originally thought. I think there are strong arguments for Murphy Brown, which was excellent but got a little too tired at the end, and Golden Girls, which was not a generational show. Additionally, I think Mary Tyler Moore could have been on there, and possibly Happy Days, though Happy Days was another show that lasted a couple years too long. I guess you could call these the second tier...

Kirsten said...

It's your fault that this song is in my head now...

You take the good,
You take the bad,
You take them both and there you have the facts of life.
The facts of life.

There's a time you gotta go and show
You're growin' now,
You know about the facts of life.
The facts of life.

When the world never seems,
To be living up to your dreams.
And suddenly you're finding out,
The facts of life are all about you.
All about you.
You-u-u-u,
A-ll about you.
It takes a lot to get em right,
But you're learnin the facts of life.
Learnin the facts of life.
Learnin the facts of life.
Learnin the facts of li-fe.
(compliments of http:// www.tripletsandus.com/80s/tvtheme.htm#TheFactsofLife

Ashley said...

I agree with all of the shows on your list (the ones I have watched). I somehow have managed to never watch a single episode of Everybody Loves Raymond; however, I don't feel any emptiness in my heart, so I will just trust that it was worthy of being on your list. :)